Friday, May 22, 2009
Some Words for The Class of '09
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Adventureland
Sitting in on a Monday night showing of Adventureland, Greg Mottola's newest ode to youth, I was struck by the realization that James's story may not be so different from my own. Our liberal arts degrees in hand, Pomona students enter the world with an appreciation for the life of the mind, but little knowledge of life itself. James, an Oberlin alum, trades the halls of the elite Ohio liberal arts college for life back home in Pittsburgh, his medieval ruminations displaced by crooked carnival games and giant ass pandas. He was supposed to travel through Europe, supposed to study journalism at Columbia, supposed to find love. Instead, he lives at home doing minimum wage work to kill time while he waits for the life he thought he'd have to start. Just as you'd expect, it never arrives. But James moves on anyway.
Tuesday, March 3, 2009
The Fact of the Matter
In his "Is Travis Kaya Up to His Old Habits of Plagiarizing the CI?," Charles Johnson of The Claremont Conservative and The Claremont Independent recently leveled some pretty hefty accusations against me regarding an article I authored for The Student Life newspaper. Published Feb. 27, the article discusses Claremont McKenna's withdrawal from the QuestBridge scholarship program, which was covered by the CI on Feb. 14. Johnson, who wrote the CI piece, says that I plagiarized the article, which is categorically false and reveals, ironically, a lack of investigation on the part of the blogger himself.
Firstly, all quotes and figures in the article were the product of my own reporting. I was in personal contact with CMC Dean of Admissions Richard Vos. All quotes from Dean Vos come from my correspondence with Dean Vos.
Secondly, The Student Life explicitly credits The Claremont Independent for the reporting that it did in its Feb. 14 piece, saying that the issue was first brought to light in that publication. It is true that my editors at The Student Life assigned me the story after learning about it in the CI, and it was duly noted. It was relevant news that TSL believed warranted coverage in its pages, albeit from a larger Pomona and 5C perspective.
Thirdly, it is obvious when comparing the CI and TSL pieces that there are a number of departure points between Johnson's reporting and my own. TSL attempted to tackle the issue from a perspective outside of the confines of CMC where Johnson centered his analysis. I include commentary from Pomona College administrators and students, where the CI piece does not. I include pertinent budget information gleaned from Trevor Hunnicutt's reporting on CMC finances, where the CI piece does not. Just as the CI provides information that TSL did not include because it did not seem immediately relevant to our readership.
Please, Mr. Johnson, descend from your high horse to take a closer look at my work before you make hasty and possibly damaging judgments. Plagiarism is not something that I take lightly, and I do not appreciate baseless accusations of plagiarism being leveled against me on such a public platform. Perhaps next time you should do a bit more investigating of your own, Charles.
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
Election Day.
Two long years of stump speeches and bumper stickers have brought us here. As Americans wake up this morning and make their way to the polls, the eyes of the world are upon them. At a time when, according to The New York Times, the future of America—and by extension, the world—“hangs in the balance,” we will all be awaiting with bated breath the outcome of what may very well be the most important election of our generation.
Personal politics aside, there’s no doubt that today’s election is a historic one. Senator Barack Obama is the nation’s first African American nominee, and Governor Sarah Palin only the second female vice presidential nominee. This is the first time in 80 years that neither candidate is an incumbent president or vice president, and the first time that both candidates have been born outside of the continental United States—McCain in Panama, Obama in Hawaii.More importantly, however, are the unprecedented problems that the 44th President of the United States of America will be inheriting come Inauguration Day. President Obama or President McCain will be forced to resolve two unpopular wars in two very unstable theatres in addition to the largest global financial crisis since the Great Depression. The president will also be responsible for righting the wrongs of the Bush Administration, overhauling economic and foreign policies that have turned world opinion against the US over the past eight years.
The truly global nature of the issues facing the next president has generated unprecedented international interest in this year’s race, especially here in the UK. In the past few weeks, much of the national and local media has dedicated considerable time to the campaigns, featuring detailed editorials on everything from the Bill Ayers kerfuffle to the comedic stylings of Tina Fey.
In Edinburgh, political organizations have sprung up in anticipation of the election. The Democrats Abroad—Scotland Chapter has taken an active role in registering American citizens living in Scotland for absentee voting, and have organized popular debate-watching parties in the city. Starting with the first presidential debate on 26 September, the group has brought together hundreds of Edinburgh Obama-supporters, including a number of non-Americans, to watch the presidential debates. Though thousands of miles away from Washington, the group provides a forum for political discourse that many in the city have found exciting in the month before the election.
Tonight, EUSA will be holding an all-night results-watching party on the big screen in Teviot for all students. In addition, election-themed meals have made their way onto the menus of the Teviot Library Bar and King’s Building House with Hawaiian and Southern flavours dominating dishes named after Obama and McCain, respectively. EUSA Vice President Services George Thomas told Student last week that “EUSA is committed to increasing involvement and raising awareness” with the election theme.
Indeed, if there’s any upside to witnessing the longest campaign cycle in recent memory, it is awareness. After two years of debates, town hall meetings and media saturation, we are all more aware of the pertinent issues and where the candidates stand on any number of them. Where previous elections have seen candidates zero in on issues like the economy or national security between the party conventions and election day, the drawn out primary process on either side of the aisle this time left no stone unturned. In 2004, Bush made it clear that he was a war president, and successfully shaped the debate around the national security question. In 2008, however, the focus drifted from ethics reform and healthcare to national security and, of course, the failing economy. The candidates have been forced to shape and reshape their campaign strategies first against members of their own party, then against those from across the aisle, giving voters a more nuanced understanding of a wider range of issues than ever before.
In recent weeks, however, a campaign once built on sound political discussion between two congenial opponents turned ugly. Sarah Palin accused Obama of “palling around” with terrorists while Obama supporters swiped at Palin’s family and intellect. At McCain rallies, supporters of the Arizona senator raised questions about Obama’s religious beliefs, equating Islam with being un-American. In Washington, pundits and members of congress openly broke out into partisan bickering, even when trying to pass emergency economic legislation. Undermining both candidates’ promise of reaching across the aisle, the election turned inevitably to partisan conflict, aiming to find and drive a wedge between blue America and red America.
Tomorrow, the political dust being kicked up in this final stretch of the campaign will begin to settle, and America will move on. No matter the results, no matter how the television talking heads spin the numbers and speculate why things turned out the way they did, there will still be only one America—neither blue nor red. It might have made political sense a week ago to race bait or use fear tactics to get those final votes in, but where will that really put us tomorrow? We can only wait to find out.
It’s almost surreal to think that the election is finally upon us. With closing arguments made, the world waits today. No matter the result, the election will change the course of global political and economic events in ways that neither we, nor the next President of the United States, can predict. As we celebrate our candidate’s victory or mourn his defeat, whoever he may be, it is time that we take a second to remember that tomorrow, we will no longer be separated by our political loyalties. Election Day is a time to celebrate a change, yes, but it also a time to reconcile. So, enjoy the day. Have an Obama burger. Or McCain burger, if you’re so inclined.
Tomorrow, the real work begins.
Monday, November 3, 2008
Embedded Reporters Go Back to the Real World
With the newspaper business continuing on its steady decline, some of the larger newspaper and television outlets found an inexpensive way this election cycle to maintain nonstop coverage of the candidates as they crisscrossed their way from battleground state to battleground state over the past two years: Campaign Embeds. (See The New York Times story published this morning.) These predominantly young and inexperienced writers are paid to follow candidates to each of their hundreds of campaign stops, serving as the eyes and ears of the elite media at each of the campaigns' backwater town rallies and urban dinner parties. It's not a glamorous job at all, and the reporters will face a harsh uphill battle come the end of November when they are thrust into today's not-so-sunny job market. If I'm still on the reporter track in 2012 though, I might be persuaded to apply. Think about it: Being able to travel cross-country on your company's dime while contributing to the first draft in history...not too shabby.
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Sorry for the Bloviation
I recently wrote an editorial for the "Comment" section of The Journal, a student publication here in Edinburgh, addressing the prevalence of US presidential election coverage on this side of the pond. Just thought I'd share, a snippet:
The presidential election brings promise of change in the international political system amidst a crumbling economy and ongoing military strife throughout the globe. For Scots and Americans alike, the election presents the chance for a sea change in international politics as usual, and a 180-degree move away from the policies of the Bush Administration. It’s an opportunity to stop and rectify the damage done to the world economy, to relations between the United Kingdom and the United States, and to Iraq. In an increasingly globalized world, America’s success is the world’s success.You can read the full text of the article here.